Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jeremy Wade's avatar

I'm a writing professor, and--as a rhetoric and composition expert who understands language is fluid and often a tool of oppression--I'd just like to cosign that shit.

Expand full comment
Sue Kocher's avatar

No apologies needed! “Y’all” is a very useful 2nd-person plural pronoun! Many other languages have one, but “proper” English does not! Well, it does, but it’s just “you” which is confusing.

This North Carolina-transplant-from-Michigan has happily adopted “y’all” for daily use (along with “might could” and many other fine southernisms), and to hell with anyone who thinks I don’t know better. We all know it’s better!

The only problem now is that somewhere along the way, “y’all” also started being used here and there for the singular “you”--perhaps as an extra polite or uppity usage, like the royal “we” to mean “I”. There’s some disagree among linguists as to when and why that happened, but it can be a little confusing to Yankees. :) But if you really need it to mean “all of you”, then “all y’all” clears that up. LOL

And you wouldn’t be you without all the rest of your southernisms--keep ‘em!

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts